Skip to main content

Search NYU Steinhardt

arch

Rating Quantitative PhD Research Proposals

Title

  • Title is clearly and concisely stated 
  • Title is well-related to proposed research

Introduction and Problem

  • Introduction is appropriate and clear
  • Problem is clearly stated
  • Sub-problems are clearly presented and contribute to the solution of the problems
  • Sub-problems are sufficient in number to solve the problem
  • Assumptions are clear
  • Limitations/delimitations are stated
  • Important terms are defined
  • Significance/need for the study is established
  • Theoretical rationale for hypotheses is evident
  • Hypotheses are clearly stated and relationship of variables is indicated

Review of Literature

  • Coverage of the literature is adequate
  • Review of the literature is well organized
  • Studies are examined critically
  • Source of important findings is noted
  • Relationship of the problem to previous research is made clear
  • Preliminary bibliography is adequate

Research Design

  • Research design is described fully
  • Research design is appropriate to solution of the problem
  • Research design is free of specific weaknesses
  • Population and sample are described
  • Method of sampling is appropriate

Data Collection

  • Data gathering methods or procedures are described
  • Data gathering methods or procedures are appropriate to the solution of the problem
  • Data gathering methods or procedures are used correctly
  • Validity and reliability of data gathering procedures are established

Data Analysis

  • Hypothesis (or problem) is re-stated and related to statistical plan
  • Statistical procedures are appropriate for problem solution

Form, Style, Suitability

  • Proposal is logically organized
  • Writing is clear and follows scholarly form
  • Proposal is suitable for degree

Qualifications of Candidate

  • Candidate has requisite academic and work experience to carry out the proposed study